From her attic in the Arizona mountains, thirty-four-year-old recluse Myra Malone blogs about a dollhouse mansion that captivates thousands of readers worldwide. Myra's stories have created legions of fans who breathlessly await every blog post, trade photographs of Mansion-modeled rooms, and swap theories about the enigmatic author. Myra herself is tethered to the Mansion by mysteries she can't understand-rooms that appear and disappear overnight, music that plays in its corridors.
Across the country, Alex Rakes, the thirty-four-year-old scion of a custom furniture business, encounters two Mansion fans trying to recreate a room. The pair show him the Minuscule Mansion, and Alex is shocked to recognize a reflection of his own life mirrored back to him in minute scale. The room is his own bedroom, and the Mansion is his family's home, handed down from the grandmother who disappeared mysteriously when Alex was a child.
Searching for answers, Alex begins corresponding with Myra. Together, the two unwind the lonely paths of their twin worlds-- big and small-- and trace the stories that entwine them, setting the stage for a meeting rooted in loss, but defined by love.
Comment: This book was published in the beginning of 2023 and the idea of it caught my attention. Recently, it was mentioned in a conversation with a friend and we decided to buddy read it, especially because it would have magical realism content, something we tend to both like in novels.
This is actually a sweet and sad story equally. There are good and cute moments/situations and others which made me feel a little sad and a little disappointed in how they were developed. I think the story, overall, is quite intriguing, but I can't be certain I appreciated the several elements together that much...
The premise is not original, but the development can be seen as such, considering the element of the miniature house. In a way, that miniature works as a replacement for the real house, where Alex lives. The story is told from his and Myra's POV, as well as chapter in the past where the focus is on Willa, Alex's grandmother and, as far as I could tell, the person linked to the house and the miniature. I couldn't quite get if she was a witch or something like it, or how exactly her connection with the house made it accept or not certain things.
In fact, this is one of the things I feel wasn't as well developed as I hoped, because I wish we could have understood better, or had more information on how the magic worked and why and how did it start, why Willa or why this way... all these possible details were not explained. I can accept that part of the allure of the novel is this lack of definition, this "magic" in the air, but since other elements weren't as strong either, in my opinion, this seemed to not be that good as well.
Myra is a hermit and we can understand that it's a mix of sadness and pain and physical scars. I kind of imagined that part of her character evolution would be for her to get past this or to discover that falling in love with Alex, her own journey could have a different meaning and her world didn't have to be only about the miniature and her house. I suppose this ended up being a way to see the end of the book (there is an HEA) but the path until there was not convincing to me. I feel the romance was very obviously set up and not as romantic as it could.
Alex is a much more intriguing character to me. He has a rocky relationship with his father (who was not welcomed in the house and who never had a good relationship with Willa, his mother) but came back to help, since his father is ill. To me, these details and how they were constructed seemed to place things in a very interesting direction, in terms of how the connection with Myra could play out, but after a few scenes here and there, I admit I started to become more and more distracted and after a while it felt as if everything was confusing and not much pay off was being given to counterbalance.
The end is quite predictable, with a few other things before that to increase the drama. Again, not much is really explained, some things are alluded to, others we can infer, but while I can understand the magical realism content and vibe, I feel not enough was explained. Plus, after a lifetime being a hermit, I feel not enough attention was given to the process of Myra accepting others, especially Alex, and while their relationship makes sense in this story, it was still a bit too whimsically done for my romantic taste.
I found the premise intriguing, but it felt like it was more fantasy than I was willing to invest into. Funny that it seems as if the worldbuilding about the magic is lacking instead--which, if I had read it, would bother me, because I'm contradictory like that.
ReplyDeleteWho knows? Perhaps you could have a different impression...
DeleteIf I had read it going off the blurb, I would have expected fantasy, and therefore I would have wanted a solid worldbuilding (meaning, for the magic to make sense and be explained enough to make sense). Your review tells me that the magic was never sufficiently explained, so I have a feeling I would have felt let down from that alone.
DeleteAnd with the main character (Myra) being flat, I think my grading would have been close to yours, perhaps lower still.
Hi! Perhaps, but other elements might be more meaningful to you instead...
DeleteThankfully, there are many books to choose instead....