So when midnight calls from the hospital come in, no one is prepared: Emily is dead at seventeen from a gunshot wound to the head, inflicted by Chris as part of an apparent suicide pact. He tells police the next bullet was meant for himself. A local detective has her doubts. And the Hartes and Golds must face every parent's worst nightmare and question: do we ever really know our children at all?
Comment: Another book by author Jodi Picoult, since it seems I kind of like her writing. I got this one at the library.
Chris and Emily have been friends since they were children because not only were their parents neighbors, but also good friends and it has been expected that Chris and Emily might even become a couple. This, in fact, did happen and all seemed to go as everyone imagined, but things suddenly change when Emily is found dead near Chris and he claims they were doing a suicide pact. But these two were perfect for each other, they had their lives ahead of them and it all pointed out that everything would be perfect. What were they hiding? Could Chris be lying? Why did they feel this was the only option?
This book was published in 1998 and I think that if the author were to write it now, certain details would really have to be different since teenagers are involved, but I think that in terms of how the theme was addressed, this story reads almost as being timeless.
I will admit that as I was starting reading and getting the information that Chris and Emily wanted to commit suicide, my mind immediately came up with a explanation I was certain had to be true, and the drama would be about it but no. I won't even say what I thought because clearly I must be ridiculous but I blame the huge amount of novels I've read by now and the need to "invent" original plots...the truth was actually a lot simpler, in a way, and way more complex in another as often life just is.
What I think this author's books are great at is in how the writing is so compelling. Yes, one might not like the story or the situations depicted, but is is a fact that the author is a good storyteller. I think that, if I were to put aside the obvious dramas and the impossibility to just guess something in someone else's mind, this story and its reason to be would be very easily avoidable. It turns out that the simplest solution was very easy: Emily should have confided in someone. How a talk, or just listening to someone can make the whole difference!
The teenagers decided to die but as the story moves along, it seems things weren't that simple, especially because Chris didn't do it and was found alive to tell his side of things. This quickly escalates into a situation in which he is considered a suspect and the story focuses a lot on his being placed in prison while awaiting for a trial. We also get to see his parents and Emily's' dealing with the aftermath of all this. In between chapters, we also have some flashbacks to explain a little how Emily went on to make this decision.
Emily's trauma is certainly valid and she should have had help. She should have found a way to tell someone. Perhaps, in this, I would say it doesn't seem very likely that she wouldn't and the pressure to be the person others think she is didn't seem to be as easy to accept as it is meant to because her parents are supportive and caring and she has a boyfriend she trusts. Although, I can also see how the author placed things in such a way that it was precisely the need to meet expectations that drove Emily to think so dramatically about what it would be not to do so. Still, from this to suicide wasn't as linear as it should, considering her personality and background.
Anyway, of course in real life we would not have such simplistic answers or things we would easily solve! I had a good reading experience, and I read way into the night to finish, something that I haven't been done recently, or because I'm distracted by social media or simply sleep, thus it was a great sensation to be this engaged in a story. Some readers commented that the end was rushed and unfair, but I kind of liked the way things went.











