English teacher Lena Wright, a spoken-word poet, can never seem to truly connect with her students. Hernan D. Hernandez is confident in front of his biology classes, but tongue-tied around the woman he most wants to impress. Down the hall, math teacher Maybelline Galang focuses on the numbers as she struggles to parent her daughter, while Coach Ray hustles his troubled football team toward another winning season. Recording it all is idealistic second-year history teacher Kaytee Mahoney, whose anonymous blog gains new readers by the day as it drifts ever further from her in-class reality. And this year, a new superintendent is determined to leave his own mark on the school—even if that means shutting the whole place down.
Comment: One more book I cannot remember why I added to my list, but it probably had something to do with the idea of having a story set in a school.
Brae Hill Valley in Texas is one of those average schools where most of the students don't come from what one would call a "balanced" home environment and that is easily reflected in how they behave at school. Still, the teachers try their best - or not - to bring the best of them and they try to help in the ways that are available to them. But what price there is for education? Schools, just like any other department which combines public workers and a target public to be served, have to reach deadlines and goals and that also affects what is necessary to be done. But is a deadline more important than the service being providing?
This is a fiction novel about a group of teachers and several other individuals who have a connection to the school world and who, somehow, interact in the context of a school year at the school where the action takes place. A good part of the plot is centered on different teachers and their personal lives, and this means the story isn't as centered on school alone, but in how this work affects everyone and not only the students. In fact, connections are endless in any environment...
The story is told in alternated chapters by several main characters, namely a few teachers whom we get to know more, considering we have their POV the longest. I can suppose each one embodies a certain trait or feature we might generalize as being "types" of teachers we see in any school, although still focused in this Texas area. I liked this vision of what the teachers go through, emotionally, in their work and as how personal lives affect professional aspects so easily to the point one's views/feelings do extrapolate into any area, actually.
Now, I have not wanted to become a teacher and I would not dream about it, mostly because it is someone with the attention on them for far too long. The idea of having students looking at a teacher does not make me want to be a teacher, at all. But I have been a student and with maturity, I can try to put myself in a teacher's shoes, so I can empathize and sympathize with the ideas intended in this book - I am assuming - and how the answer to the problems seems to always end up in the same thing. Education requires a lot more investment, financially, for the dedication and professionalism of teachers to bear results.
If the real solution were to be simple there would not need for the subject to be discussed, though, and I cannot really say what should be done... perhaps a different way of looking at what it means to provide an education? Changing the educational system? I'm certain experts have better ideas
Regarding this novel, what seems more obvious is that the area/region and its associated cultural and social struggles certainly affect how a school is seen by students. It seems the author tried to convey a realistic idea of the type of situations and expectations students from low income areas face, and how there is this inherent expectation that some students won't go far. However, politically speaking, this isn't good publicity so the weight of the guilt seems to be transferred into teachers and they are also being evaluated, while trying to keep up with norms, deficiency in having materials and time to help students while being forced to reach a deadline.
To be fair, I didn't connect with any character in this novel because the characterizations seemed quite superficial, but I think the author did manage to show that any teacher is also a human being with personal issues, and people are not machines, to provide things in linear and perfect ways. I kind of expected to have more school scenes, or related to school stuff. But, ultimately, I'd say this is a story about teachers, and not about schools.
Some scenes were quite thought provoking, especially a particular one in which a teacher finally looses control and reprimands a student, without having done it before. It might seem unimportant and the student had been described as lacking attention and interest, but... the behavior changes. How much of what is supposed to be school success is actually a safe place in one's mind? We cannot control what happens to students and what they really think, so does a teacher really affect student's vision of themselves as easily?

No comments:
Post a Comment